Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 329-334
Awareness of brain death, organ donation, and transplantation among medical students at single academic institute
Hani A Alnajjar1, Maan Alzahrani2, Muath Alzahrani2, Mazen Banweer2, Essam Alsolami2, Azzam Alsulami2
1 Department of Anesthesia, University of Jeddah, Hamzah Ibn Al Qasim Street, Al Sharafeyah, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
2 Medical Student, University of Jeddah, Hamzah Ibn Al Qasim Street, Al Sharafeyah, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Dr. Hani A Alnajjar
Assistant Professor of Anesthesia, University of Jeddah, Assistant, Hamzah Ibn Al Qasim Street, Al Sharafeyah, Jeddah - 23218
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
|Date of Submission||24-Dec-2019|
|Date of Decision||31-Jan-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||16-Jan-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||30-May-2020|
Objective: To assess the knowledge of the concept of brain death, attitude, and level of awareness towards organ donation and transplantation, among medical students and interns at the University of Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Methods: A cross-sectional study via electronic questionnaire over period of 3 weeks to 2nd through 6th year medical students and interns at university of Jeddah.
Results: A response rate of 113 out of 151 (74.83%) was achieved. Among participants, 36% expressed uncertainty when questioned about the concept of brain death. 8.8% of the participants were against the idea of organ donation. 60% of those who refused to contemplate organ donation were unfamiliar with the brain death concept. No significant difference was seen regarding fears about cosmetic disfiguration between those familiar and unfamiliar with the concept of brain death. 60.2% of the study cohort would consider donating their organs to family members but only 29.2% of them had discussed the matter of organ donation and transplantation with them, while 44.2% had discussed the matter with their friends. Majority of medical students (71.7%) were interested in being organ donors.
Conclusion: Knowledge of organ donation and transplantation were adequate. Matter accepting brain death and its implication still not clear for most of participants. We believe there is still room to improve. This could be achieved by integrating more education about different aspects of brain death and its implications through medical school years.
Keywords: Brain death; knowledge; medical students; organ donation
|How to cite this article:|
Alnajjar HA, Alzahrani M, Alzahrani M, Banweer M, Alsolami E, Alsulami A. Awareness of brain death, organ donation, and transplantation among medical students at single academic institute. Saudi J Anaesth 2020;14:329-34
|How to cite this URL:|
Alnajjar HA, Alzahrani M, Alzahrani M, Banweer M, Alsolami E, Alsulami A. Awareness of brain death, organ donation, and transplantation among medical students at single academic institute. Saudi J Anaesth [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 20];14:329-34. Available from: http://www.saudija.org/text.asp?2020/14/3/329/285452
| Introduction|| |
Brain death implies the irreversible absence of cerebral and brainstem function. In most countries brain death is understood as the death of a person. Most organ donors are patients who meet the criteria for neurologic brain-death.
Organ transplantation has saved hundreds and thousands of lives in patients with end-organ failure. There is a lack of organ donors globally; more than 20% of patients on waiting lists die every year due to lack of donor organs. Uncertainty about brain death concept and adverse religious beliefs of the general population play an important role in affecting the decision to donate cadaveric organs for transplantation.
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia established the Saudi Center for Organ Transplantation (SCOT) to supervise organ donation and the transplantation program. There has been a subsequent annual increase in the number of transplanted organs.
In 2016, potential brain-dead donors numbered 646, with 410 deemed potential donors, 333 eligible, 92 actual donors and 85 utilized. Since 1986, the possible deceased brain death donors reached 11866, 7257 potentials, 6119 eligible, 2020 actual donors, and 1816 actual cases. However, with the increased demand for organ transplantation, number of actual cases is not necessarily increased. Increasing awareness and education of organ donation need is becoming crucial in the society.
Health care providers have important role in affecting public awareness regarding brain death and organ donation, and therefore medical students' awareness and acceptance of the subject are important in affecting health workers practicing and the community beliefs about brain death and organ donation in the future, as they represent the future physicians.
Few studies have assessed the knowledge and awareness of the concept of brain death among students. A cross sectional study in Spain on 9275 medical students in 2010 indicated that 67% of students have adequate knowledge about brain death while 28% didn't know the meaning of brain death and 5% didn't believe brain death heralded the de facto death of a person.
Prince Sultan Military College of Health Sciences (Saudi Arabia) surveyed 434 health students to analyze their attitude toward organ donation. 44% of the students had a positive attitude toward donation.
| Aim|| |
Knowledge and awareness assesment of medical students and interns regarding brain death, organ donation and transplantation.
| Methodology|| |
Study design and setting
The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Medical College at the University of Jeddah (IRB No. 642-19). A cross sectional study was carried out at the University of Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, in January 2019. All undergraduate medical students from second to sixth years and intern were considered eligible to participate. 1st year medical students excluded as curriculum involve basic science only. All participants were notified about the study objectives, response confidentiality, and consent to participate obtained electronically.
We used stratified sampling and the calculated sample was 109 out of 151 medical students to achieve 95% confidence level. This was calculated using Raosoft software (Raosoft, Seattle, WA, USA).
Permission was taken from Rios et al. to use their questionnaire, and to adapt it based on local cultural norms and practice. An anonymous questionnaire was used and distributed as an electronic form using Google forms and the data was collected by spread excel sheet. The questionnaire contains two part; One part of the questionnaire demonstrated demographic distribution while the other were related to research topic (brain death and organ donation).
Brain death concept and students' knowledge were categorized to one of the following:
Correct concept: Identifying brain death as the de facto death of a person.
Incorrect concept: Not identifying brain death as a person's death.
Unknown concept: Lack of awareness of the concept of brain death.
The survey contained 29 questions and was divided into four parts. The 1st part dealt with personal data and social variables, the 2nd part dealt with the variability of knowledge about donation and transplantations, the 3rd part about variables of a religious nature and the 4th part attitude to organ donation and transplantation.
Descriptive statistics were used to present respondents' socio-demographic characteristics, questions related to organ donation and brain death. Comparisons between respondents' knowledge of brain death and was the association between brain death knowledge and socio-demographic characteristics, was performed using the Chi-square test.
The analysis was performed using the Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS), version 23.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA).
| Results|| |
A total of 113 individuals responded. The median age was 22 years old; the overwhelming majority of the respondents were male 106 (93.8%) as female medical college started two year ago. All respondents were Saudi nationals [Table 1].
Twenty-three (20.4%) respondents had a family member or friend who needed an organ transplant. Only 18 (15.9%) respondents thought that the need for organ transplantation need was met. [Table 2] shows all organ transplantation knowledge-related responses for all study participants and participants split by knowledge of brain death. No statistically significant difference was found between the groups (all P values > 0.05) [Table 2].
[Chart 1] shows respondents' source of information regarding organ donation. 62.8% of respondents stated that the most prominent source of information favoring of organ donation was health professionals. 18.6% of respondents stated that the source of information not in favor of donation was “family”. Only 1.8% respondents received knowledge from social media [Chart 1].
Organ donation related behavior/attitude-related questions are presented in [Table 3]. Differences in responses between the groups did not reach statistical significance (P values >0.05) [Table 3]. Only fourteen (12%) respondents knew brain death is a terminal event with no possibility of recovery or resolution [Chart 2].
The Chi-square test was applied to assess the association between brain death knowledge and socio-demographic characteristics. No statistically significant association was found (P-values > 0.05) [Table 4].
|Table 4: Association between knowledge of brain death and socio-demographic variables|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Knowledge of medical students and their attitude toward brain death and organ donation is important in addressing issues of deficiency in the medical curriculum, ensuring that doctors who are graduating are able to advocate for organ donation once they join the medical workforce but also to improve public awareness.,
Other studies have assessed the knowledge of brain death and organ donation among medical students. However, there are few studies have assessed the attitude toward organ donation among university students in Saudi Arabia.
In the present study, only 59.52% of medical students understood the brain death concept, while 40.36% expressed uncertainty as to whether brain death was synonymous with patient demise.
In comparison to studies of Japan, Spain, and America that assessed the knowledge of the brain death concept among medical students, our study shows that the general knowledge about the concept was in adequate range. Despite this, the level of understanding and knowledge among Saudi medical students needs to be improved. This can be achieved by exposure during clinical clerkships, formalized study of brain death criteria and transplant surgery and principles.
Our results indicate that a majority of students surveyed are aware of the importance of organ donation. 60.2% expressed a willingness to donate the organs of family members were they to be diagnosed with brain death, while 31.9% were not sure if they would. 55.8% were willing to donate their own organs, with 23% concerned about being scarred or mutilated as a result of organ extraction.
Student's opinions could be affected by their family and community, 18.6% affected negatively by family opinion followed by movies (16.8%) and friends (13.3%). Religious beliefs of a community may affect personal decision toward donation of cadaveric organs for transplantation but we did not navigate through it.,
Saudi center for organ transplantation (SCOT) has prepared programs and contributed to the increase the number of donors over the years, and there are some results have shown an improvement in public responses toward consent for organ donation.,
Even with increasing of donors in Saudi Arabia, there is still shortage of organs for transplantation.,
There are several limitations of this study. Owing to the curriculum design, medical students in the basic science years (second and third years) have limited access to hospitalized patients, in contrast to students in the clinical years (fourth, fifth, and sixth years) and interns. We also restricted our survey to students of one institution and as a result, it is uncertain if these results are generalizable to the entire medical student body in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
| Conclusion|| |
Regarding attitude toward organ donation, there is no big difference between medical students with brain death knowledge and students without brain death knowledge. Comparing with other countries our results show that we are in the average. We recommend doing the same study in more universities and colleges in Saudi Arabia so these studies can be generalized and also to improve medical students' knowledge and awareness for organ donation.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Ríos A, López-Navas A, López-López A, Gómez FJ, Iriarte J, Herruzo R, et al
. Do Spanish medical students understand the concept of brain death? Prog Transplant 2018;28:77-82.
Youn TS, Greer DM. Brain death and management of a potential organ donor in the intensive care unit. Crit Care Clin 2014;30:813-31.
Arbour R. Clinical management of the organ donor. AACN Clin Issues 2005;16:551-80; quiz 600-1.
Cantarovich F. Improvement in organ shortage through education. Transplantation 2002;73:1844-6.
Cantarovich F. Public opinion and organ donation suggestions for overcoming barriers. Ann Transplant 2005;10:22-5.
Saudi Center for Organ Transplantation. Directory of the Regulations of Organ Transplantation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 2nd
ed. Saudi Arabia: Saudi Health Council; 2014. Available from: http://www.scot.gov.sa/webb/Str/42?lang=En
. [Last accessed 2016 Dec 09].
Alam AA. Public opinion on organ donation in Saudi Arabia. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2007;18:54.
] [Full text]
Shaheen FA, Souqiyyeh MZ. Increasing organ donation rates from Muslim donors: Lessons from a successful model. Transplant Proc 2004;36:1878-80. Elsevier.
Schaeffner ES, Windisch W, Freidel K, Breitenfeldt K, Winkelmayer WC. Knowledge and attitude regarding organ donation among medical students and physicians. Transplantation 2004;77:1714-8.
Elsafi SH, Al-Adwani MM, Al-Jubran KM, Hassan MA, Al Zahrani EM. Factors influencing the willingness of allied health students to donate organs or tissues. Transplant Proc 2017;49:1215-20. Elsevier.
Ohwaki K, Yano E, Shirouzu M, Kobayashi A, Nakagomi T, Tamura A. Factors associated with attitude and hypothetical behaviour regarding brain death and organ transplantation: Comparison between medical and other university students. Clin Transplant 2006;20:416-22.
Tawil I, Gonzales SM, Marinaro J, Timm TC, Kalishman S, Crandall CS. Do medical students understand brain death? A survey study. J Surg Educ 2012;69:320-5.
Aghaee MA, Dehghani M, Sadeghi MA, Khaleghi E. Awareness of religious leaders' fatwa and willingness to donate organ. Int J Organ Transplant Med 2015;6:158.
Aldawood A, Al Qahtani S, Dabbagh O, Al-Sayyari AA. Organ donation after brain-death: Experience over five-years in a tertiary hospital. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2007;18:60.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]